Slavoj Žižek’s Philosophy in the Researches of Chinese Scholars: Between Marxism and Psychoanalysis
##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.main##
##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.sidebar##
Abstract
The paper analyzes the history and the present state of the study of Slavoj Žižek’s philosophy in China, which mainly concerns his concept of ideology, criticism of popular culture and contemporary globalized capitalism. It is shown that the beginning of scientific researches of Žižek’s philosophy in China in the late 1990s and early 2000s was associated with the scholar seminars and the first translations of the Slovenian thinker’s works into Chinese language (Wang Fengzhen, Ji Guangmao). It is noted that at the present stage, Chinese scholars are focused on the following issues in the study of Žižek’s works: the concept of ideology; the influence of the ideas of G. Hegel, K. Marx and J. Lacan; literary and artistic theory and aesthetic thought; criticism of modern capitalism, science and society. The comparative studies were analyzed in order to determine the ideological origins of the concept of Žižek’s concept of ideology (Zhang Yibing, Zhang Xiuqin, Liu Shiheng, Tang Zhengdong, Xia Ying, Han Zhenjiang, Mo Lei, Wang Yue, Kong Ming’an, Tan Yong). The study of the influence of the late Lacanian psychoanalytic theory on the formation of Žižek’s philosophy is an important direction in the works of Wan Shuhui, Meng Xianli, Cui Zanmei, Yuan Xiaoyun. The author explores the formation of Žižek’s concept of the subject from the standpoint of psychoanalysis in the works of Mo Lei, Han Zhenjiang, Liu Xinting, Kong Ming’an and Shi Liyuan. The particular attention is paid to the study of psychoanalytic literary and artistic theory and aesthetic thought of Žižek in the works of Yu Qi, Chen Qijia, Chen Xihe, Wan Chuanfa, Liu Xinting, Hu Jihua, Han Zhenjiang, Sun Bai, Yang Hanxu, Ceng Sheng and Nan Ye. The approaches to Žižek’s criticism of modern capitalism, science and society are defined in the works of Zhang Lijun, Zhang Jian, Yu Qi, Sun Liangjie, Liu Mingming, Xia Yinping, Xin Haifeng, Lu Yufeng, Liu Yunshan. It is emphasized that, according to many Chinese scholars, Žižek’s philosophy has great theoretical and practical importance for understanding the contemporary social reality and rethinking the theory of ideology.
How to Cite
##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.details##
Marxism, psychoanalysis, theory, criticism, subject, real, science, capitalism, socialism
Zhang Yiwu. Žižek’s China, China’s Žižek // Positions: East Asia cultures critique. Vol. 19, No. 3. 2011. https://doi.org/10.1215/10679847-1369280
曾胜。影像中的征兆合成人——论齐泽克的拉康主义电影研究 // 浙江传媒学院学报。第2期。2012.
陈奇佳。主体的倾覆与人的命运——齐泽克论悲剧 // 戏剧 (中央戏剧学院学报)。第3期。2021.
陈犀禾、万传法。对电影“凝视”的一次哲学思考 // 电影艺术, 第3期。2007.
韩振江。齐泽克意识形态理论研究。北京, 2009.
韩振江。齐泽克:新马克思主义批判哲学。北京, 2014.
韩振江。齐泽克眼中的电影: 幻象艺术 // 中国图书评论, 第5期。2015.
韩振江。齐泽克与马克思主义。北京, 2017.
何李新。齐泽克论希区柯克——精神分析电影理论的重构 // 四川戏剧。第1期。2015.
胡继华。穿越幻象——齐泽克为观察电影提供的一个视角 // 文艺研究。第3期。2013.
胡顺。论齐泽克对平衡自然观的批判 // 世界哲学, 第 5期。2020a.
胡顺。论齐泽克精神分析哲学视野下的生态危机 // 理论界。第 3期。2020b.
季广茂。寻找崩溃点——齐泽克及其意识形态理论浅说 // 国外理论动态。第2期。2003.
孔明安、谭勇。交往的主体与生成的主体——哈贝马斯与齐泽克的主体间性思想比较研究 // 安徽师范大学学报 (人文社会科学版)。第3期。2020a.
孔明安、谭勇。异化的实体与主体的实体——齐泽克对马克思资本哲学思想的新探讨 // 山东社会科学, 第7期。2020b.
孔明安、谭勇 (2021), “分裂•幻象•驱力——论齐泽克精神分析视域下主体的三个维度”, 哲学分析, 第3期, 页120–131+198.
孔明安、石立元。论驱力主体的生成与解放逻辑——从康德的根本恶到齐泽克的恶魔之恶的反转 // 马克思主义与现实。第4期。2021.
刘魁。齐泽克、自然失衡与绿色技术的价值重估 // 江苏行政学院学报。 第 5期。2020.
刘世衡。齐泽克与马克思意识形态观的比较研究 // 理论导刊。第1期。2010.
刘世衡。难以摆脱的幻象缠绕。北京, 2011.
刘同舫。穿越幻象:齐泽克意识形态批判及其解放态度 // 教学与研究。第11期。2018.
刘昕亭。除不尽的齐泽克––国 内 齐 泽 克 研 究 综 述 // 外国文学。第 5 期。2012.
刘昕亭。齐泽克的凝视理论与电影凝视的重构 // 文艺研究。第2期。2018a.
刘昕亭。作为政治批评的缝合式批评——齐泽克研究 // 文学与文化。第3期。2018b.
刘昕亭。后人类话语反思——以齐泽克为中心 // 文艺理论研究。第 6期。2020.
刘云杉。论齐泽克对当代资本主义的政治哲学批判 // 天府新论。第 3期。2021.
陆寓丰。全球化资本主义的症候及其反抗——评齐泽克对于毛泽东“矛盾论”的后现代式阅读 // 毛泽东研究。第 2期。2020.
孟献丽、崔赞梅 。齐泽克的意识形态幻象理论及其评析 // 世界哲学。第2期。2020.
莫雷。穿越意识形态的幻象——齐泽克意识形态理论研究 // 理论探讨。第3期。2008.
莫雷。穿越意识形态的幻象。北京, 2012.
南野。齐泽克或齐泽克式的电影读解 // 当代电影。第10期。2013.
齐泽克。意识形态的崇高客体。北京, 2002.
齐泽克。易碎的绝对。南京, 2003.
齐泽克。快感大转移。南京, 2004a.
齐泽克。实在界的面庞。北京, 2004b.
齐泽克。与齐泽克对话。南京, 2005.
齐泽克。幻想的瘟疫。南京, 2006a.
齐泽克。敏感的主体。南京, 2006b.
齐泽克。图绘意识形态。南京, 2006c.
齐泽克。不敢问希区柯克的, 就问拉康吧。上海, 2007a.
齐泽克。因为他们并不知道他们所做的。南京, 2007b.
齐泽克。伊拉克: 借来的壶。北京, 2008.
齐泽克。斜目而视。杭州, 2011.
齐泽克。欢迎来到实在界这个大荒漠。南京, 2012.
齐泽克。享受你的症状: 好莱坞内外的拉康。南京, 2014.
齐泽克。延迟的否定。南京, 2016.
齐泽克。齐泽克的笑话。郑州, 2017a.
齐泽克。突破可能性的极限。福州, 2017b.
齐泽克。真实眼泪之可怖。武汉, 2018.
史凤阁。自然中心主义生态观的批判与新生态哲学的建构 // 国外社会科学。第 2期。2021.
苏平富。意识形态的秘密: “他者的短缺” 或 “真实的缺失” ––齐泽克意识形态理论初探 //哲学研究。第8期。2006.
孙柏。实在界之快感: 齐泽克电影批评对拉康理论的应用 // 中国人民大学学报。第6期。2011a.
孙柏。希区柯克的应答——但要去问齐泽克 // 文学与文化。第8期。2011b.
孙柏。从缝合到界面:齐泽克论基耶斯洛夫斯基世界的重影 // 四川戏剧。第1期。2016.
孙亮洁、刘明明。 论齐泽克对韩炳哲“自我剥削”理论的批判及对共产主义的辩护 // 天府新论。第 6期。2020.
谭勇、孔明安。人工智能将会成为一种新主体吗?——齐泽克精神分析视野下的人工智能研究 // 国外理论动态。第 4期。2021.
唐正东。齐泽克的犬儒主义意识形态观批判 // 江西社会科学。第11期。2015.
万书辉。文化文本的互文性书写。成都, 2007.
王逢振。齐泽克: 批评界的一颗新星 // 外国文学。第3期。1999.
王茜。齐泽克 “意识形态的崇高客体” 的意义 // 社会科学战线。第1期。2004.
汪行福。从商品拜物教到犬儒主义——齐泽克意识形态论研究 // 马克思主义与现实。第3期。2007.
汪玥。齐泽克对马克思拜物教理论的分析——以原始 “礼物” 观为研究对象 // 美与时代。第7期。2020.
夏银平、辛海风。齐泽克话语中的列宁式革命研究 // 学术研究。 第 3期。2021.
夏莹。无 “物” 的拜物, 无 “主体” 的迷恋——齐泽克对马克思商品拜物教理论的拉康化解读 // 学 术月刊。第11期。2007.
杨晗旭。对实在界的斜目而视——评齐泽克对电影的拉康式解读 //电影评介。第4期。2013.
于琦。论齐泽克反抵抗政治的理论取向 // 当代外国文学。第2期。2011.
于琦。齐泽克文化批评研究。北京, 2012.
袁小云。关于齐泽克意识形态理论研究述评 // 宜春学院学报。第33 卷, 第9 期。2011.
袁小云。齐泽克的意识形态理论述评 // 求索。第3期。2012.
张剑。齐泽克的生态危机思想解读 // 哲学动态。第1期。2011.
张剑。齐泽克:将正义之思逼入深渊 // 理论探讨。第4期。2015.
張歷君。穿越9.11的幻象: 讀齊澤克的 “歡迎光臨真實的荒漠” // 南方論叢。3月, 第一期。2009.
张秀琴。虚假意识与幻像现实: 马克思与齐泽克意识形态理论比较 // 辽宁大学学报 (哲学社会科学 版)。第7期。2007.
张一兵。社会症候与非完全拜物教––齐泽克“意识形态的崇高对象”解读 // 理论探讨。第5期。2004.
张一兵。文本的深度耕犁––第二卷––后马克思思潮哲学文本解读。北京, 2008.
张兆卉。国内齐泽克电影理论研究综述 // 北方文学。第 5 期。2018.
赵睿夫。齐泽克的“批判教育学”及其当代启示 // 当代教育与文化。第 3期。2021.
周维功。“道德恐惧”辩 // 江淮论坛。第 5期。2015.
周治健、高福进。论暴力背后的隐秘图景——齐泽克政治哲学视角 // 马克思主义与现实。第 1期。2017.
REFERENCES
Zhang Yiwu (2011), “Žižek’s China, China’s Žižek”, Positions: East Asia cultures critique, Vol. 19, No. 3, pp. 723–737. https://doi.org/10.1215/10679847-1369280
Ceng Sheng (2012), “Yingxiang zhong de zhengzhao hecheng ren——lun Qizeke de Lakang zhuyi dianying yanjiu”, Zhejiang chuanmei xueyuan xuebao, No. 2, pp. 59–63. (In Chinese).
Chen Qijia (2021), “Zhuti de qingfu yu ren de mingyun——Qizeke lun beiju”, Xiju (Zhongyang xiju xueyuan xuebao), No. 3, pp. 1–19. (In Chinese).
Chen Xihe, Wan Chuanfa (2007), “Dui dianying “ningshi” de yici zhexue sikao”, Dianying yishu, No. 3, pp. 151–153. (In Chinese).
Han Zhenjiang (2009), Qizeke yishi xingtai lilun yanjiu, Renmin chubanshe, Beijing. (In Chinese).
Han Zhenjiang (2014), Qizeke: Xin makesi zhuyi pipan zhexue, Renmin chubanshe, Beijing. (In Chinese).
Han Zhenjiang (2015), “Qizeke yanzhong de dianying: Huanxiang yishu”, Zhongguo tushu pinglun, No. 5, pp. 81–88. (In Chinese).
Han Zhenjiang (2017), Qizeke yu makesi zhuyi, Renmin chubanshe, Beijing. (In Chinese).
He Lixin (2015), “Qizeke lun Xiqukeke——jingshen fenxi dianying lilun de zhong gou”, Sichuan xiju, No. 1, pp. 103–106. (In Chinese).
Hu Jihua (2013), “Chuanyue huanxiang——Qizeke wei guancha dianying tigong de yige shijiao”, Wenyi yanjiu, No. 3, pp. 16–24. (In Chinese).
Hu Shun (2020a), “Lun Qizeke dui pingheng ziran guan de pipan”, Shijie zhexue, No. 5, pp. 48–55. (In Chinese).
Hu Shun (2020b), “Lun Qizeke jingshen fenxi zhexue shiye xia de shengtai weiji”, Lilun jie, No. 3, pp. 48–54. (In Chinese).
Ji Guangmao (2003), “Xunzhao bengkui dian——Qizeke ji qi yishi xingtai lilun qianshuo”, Guowai lilun dongtai, No. 2, pp. 42–45. (In Chinese).
Kong Ming’an, Tan yong (2020a), “Jiaowang de zhuti yu shengcheng de zhuti——Habeimasi yu Qizeke de zhuti jian xing sixiang bijiao yanjiu”, Anhui shifan daxue xuebao (Renwen shehui kexue ban), No. 3, pp. 47–54. (In Chinese).
Kong Ming’an, Tan yong (2020b), “Yihua de shiti yu zhuti de shiti——Qizeke dui Makesi ziben zhexue sixiang de xin tantao”, Shandong shehui kexue, No. 7, pp. 5–13. (In Chinese).
Kong Ming’an, Tan Yong (2021), “Fenlie•huanxiang•qu li——lun Qizeke jingshen fenxi shi yu xia zhuti de san ge weidu”, Zhexue fenxi, No. 3, pp. 120–131+198. (In Chinese).
Kong Ming’an, Shi Liyuan (2021), “Lun qu li zhuti de shengcheng yu jiefang luoji——cong Kangde de genben e dao Qizeke de emo zhi e de fan zhuan”, Makesi zhuyi yu xianshi, No. 4, pp. 104–110. (In Chinese).
Liu Kui (2020), “Qizeke, ziran shiheng yu lüse jishu de jiazhi zhong gu”, Jiangsu xingzheng xueyuan xuebao, No. 5, pp. 21–27. (In Chinese).
Liu Shiheng (2010), “Qizeke yu Makesi yishi xingtai guan de bijiao yanjiu”, Lilun daokan, No. 1, pp. 37–39. (In Chinese).
Liu Shiheng (2011), Nanyi baituo de huanxiang chanrao, Zhishi chanquan chubanshe, Beijing. (In Chinese).
Liu Tongfang (2018), “Chuanyue huanxiang: Qizeke yishi xingtai pipan ji qi jiefang taidu”, Jiaoxue yu yanjiu, No. 11, pp. 75–80. (In Chinese).
Liu Xinting (2012), “Chu bu jin de Qizeke––guonei Qizeke yanjiu zongshu”, Waiguo wenxue, No. 5, pp. 120–128. (In Chinese).
Liu Xinting (2018a), “Qizeke de ningshi lilun yu dianying ningshi de zhong gou”, Wenyi yanjiu, No. 2, pp. 97–107. (In Chinese).
Liu Xinting (2018b), “Zuowei zhengzhi piping de fenghe shi piping—— Qizeke yanjiu”, Wenxue yu wenhua, No. 3, pp. 38–45. (In Chinese).
Liu Xinting (2020), “Hou renlei huayu fansi——yi Qizeke wei zhongxin”, Wenyi lilun yanjiu, No. 6, pp. 184–191. (In Chinese).
Liu Yunshan (2021), “Lun Qizeke dui dangdai ziben zhuyi de zhengzhi zhexue pipan”, Tianfu xin lun, No. 3, pp. 14–21. (In Chinese).
Lu Yufeng (2020), “Quanqiu hua ziben zhuyi de zhenghou ji qi fankang——ping Qizeke duiyu Mao Zedong “maodun lun” de hou xiandai shi yuedu”, Mao Zedong yanjiu, No. 2, pp. 105–111. (In Chinese).
Meng Xianli, Cui Zanmei (2020), “Qizeke de yishi xingtai huanxiang lilun ji qi pingxi”, Shijie zhexue, No. 2, pp. 61–70. (In Chinese).
Mo Lei (2008), “Chuanyue yishi xingtai de huanxiang——Qizeke yishi xingtai lilun yanjiu”, Lilun tantao, No. 3, pp. 55–58. (In Chinese).
Mo Lei (2012), Chuanyue yishi xingtai de huanxiang, Zhongguo shehui kexue chubanshe, Beijing. (In Chinese).
Nan Ye (2013), “Qizeke huo Qizeke shi de dianying du jie”, Dangdai dianying, No. 10, pp. 185–188. (In Chinese).
Qizeke (2002), Yishi xingtai de chonggao keti, Zhongyang bianyi chubanshe, Beijing. (In Chinese).
Qizeke (2003), Yisui de juedui, Jiangsu renmin chubanshe, Nanjing. (In Chinese).
Qizeke (2004a), Kuaigan da zhuanyi, Jiangsu renmin chubanshe, Nanjing. (In Chinese).
Qizeke (2004b), Shizai jie de mianpang, Zhongyang bianyi chubanshe, Beijing. (In Chinese).
Qizeke (2005), Yu Qizeke duihua, Jiangsu renmin chubanshe, Nanjing. (In Chinese).
Qizeke (2006a), Huanxiang de wenyi, Jiangsu renmin chubanshe, Nanjing. (In Chinese).
Qizeke (2006b), Mingan de zhuti, Jiangsu renmin chubanshe, Nanjing. (In Chinese).
Qizeke (2006c), Tu hui yishi xingtai, Nanjing daxue chubanshe, Nanjing. (In Chinese).
Qizeke (2007a), Bu gan wen Xiqukeke de, jiu wen Lakang ba, Shanghai renmin chubanshe, Shanghai. (In Chinese).
Qizeke (2007b), Yinwei tamen bing bu zhidao tamen suo zuo de, Jiangsu renmin chubanshe, Nanjing. (In Chinese).
Qizeke (2008), Yilake: Jielai de hu, Sanlian shudian, Beijing. (In Chinese).
Qizeke (2011), Xie mu er shi, Zhejiang daxue chubanshe, Hangzhou. (In Chinese).
Qizeke (2012), Huanying lai dao shizai jie zhege da huangmo, Yilin chubanshe, Nanjing. (In Chinese).
Qizeke (2014), Xiangshou ni de zhengzhuang: Haolaiwu neiwai de Lakang, Nanjing daxue chubanshe, Nanjing. (In Chinese).
Qizeke (2016), Yanchi de fouding, Nanjing daxue chubanshe, Nanjing. (In Chinese).
Qizeke (2017a), Qizeke de xiaohua, Henan daxue chubanshe, Zhengzhou. (In Chinese).
Qizeke (2017b), Tupo keneng xing de jixian, Fujian jiaoyu chubanshe, Fuzhou. (In Chinese).
Qizeke (2018), Zhenshi yanlei zhi ke bu, Wuhan daxue chubanshe, Wuhan. (In Chinese).
Shi Fengge (2021), “Ziran zhongxin zhuyi shengtai guan de pipan yu xin shengtai zhexue de jiangou”, Guowai shehui kexue, No. 2, pp. 57–64. (In Chinese).
Su Pingfu (2006), “Yishi xingtai de mimi: “Ta zhe de duanque” huo “zhenshi de queshi”––Qizeke yishi xingtai lilun chutan”, Zhexue yanjiu, No. 8, pp. 66–70. (In Chinese).
Sun Bai (2011a), “Shizai jie zhi kuaigan: Qizeke dianying piping dui Lakang lilun de yingyong”, Zhongguo renmin daxue xuebao, No. 6, pp. 52–59. (In Chinese).
Sun Bai (2011b), “Xiqukeke de yingda——dan yao qu wen Qizeke”, Wenxue yu wenhua, No. 8, pp. 71–74. (In Chinese).
Sun Bai (2016), “Cong fenghe dao jiemian: Qizeke lun Jiyesiluofusiji shijie de chong ying”, Sichuan xiju, No. 1, pp. 126–130. (In Chinese).
Sun Liangjie, Liu Mingming (2020), “Lun Qizeke dui Han Bingzhe “ziwo boxue” lilun de pipan ji dui gongchan zhuyi de bianhu”, Tianfu xin lun, No. 6, pp. 10–19. (In Chinese).
Tan Yong, Kong Ming’an (2021), “Rengong zhineng jiang hui chengwei yi zhong xin zhuti ma?—— Qizeke jingshen fenxi shiye xia de rengong zhineng yanjiu”, Guowai lilun dongtai, No. 4, pp. 147–154. (In Chinese).
Tang Zhengdong (2015), “ Qizeke de quanru zhuyi yishi xingtai guan pipan”, Jiangxi shehui kexue, No. 11, pp. 5–10. (In Chinese).
Wan Shuhui (2007), Wenhua wenben de huwenxing shuxie, Bashu shushe, Chengdu. (In Chinese).
Wang Fengzhen (1999), “Qizeke: Piping jie de yi ke xinxing”, Waiguo wenxue, No. 3, pp. 66–70. (In Chinese).
Wang Qian (2004), “Qizeke ‘yishi xingtai de chonggao keti’ de yiyi”, Shehui kexue zhanxian, No. 1, pp. 238–242. (In Chinese).
Wang Xingfu (2007), “Cong shangpin baiwujiao dao quanru zhuyi—— Qizeke yishi xingtai lun yanjiu”, Makesi zhuyi yu xianshi, No. 3, pp. 25–33. (In Chinese).
Wang Yue (2020), “Qizeke dui Makesi baiwujiao lilun de fenxi——yi yuanshi ‘liwu’ guan wei yan jiu duixiang”, Mei yu shidai, No. 7, pp. 23–25. (In Chinese).
Xia Yinping, Xin Haifeng (2021), “Qizeke huayu zhong di liening shi geming yanjiu”, Xueshu yanjiu, No. 3, pp. 11–16. (In Chinese).
Xia Ying (2007), “Wu ‘wu’ de bai wu, wu ‘zhuti’ de milian——Qizeke dui Makesi shangpin baiwujiao lilun de Lakang hua jiedu”, Xueshu yuekan, No. 11, pp. 53–58. (In Chinese).
Yang Hanxu (2013), “Dui shizai jie de xie mu er shi——ping Qizeke dui dianying de Lakang shi jiedu”, Dianying pingjie, No. 4, pp. 64–65+81. (In Chinese).
Yu Qi (2011), “Lun Qizeke fan dikang zhengzhi de lilun quxiang”, Dangdai waiguo wenxue, No. 2, pp. 30–41. (In Chinese).
Yu Qi (2012), Qizeke wenhua piping yanjiu, Zhongguo shehui kexue chubanshe, Beijing. (In Chinese).
Yuan Xiaoyun (2011), “Guanyu Qizeke yishi xingtai lilun yanjiu shuping”, Yichun xueyuan xuebao, Vol. 33, No. 9, pp. 9–11. (In Chinese).
Yuan Xiaoyun (2012), “Qizeke de yishi xingtai lilun shuping”, Qiusuo, No. 3, pp. 110–112. (In Chinese).
Zhang Jian (2011), “Qizeke de shengtai weiji sixiang jiedu”, Zhexue dongtai, No. 1, pp. 43–47. (In Chinese).
Zhang Jian (2015), “Qizeke: Jiang zhengyi zhi si bi ru shenyuan”, Lilun tantao, No. 4, pp. 59–63. (In Chinese).
Zhang Lijun (2009), “Chuanyue 9.11 de huanxiang: Du Qizeke de ‘huanying guanglin zhenshi de huangmo’ ”, Nanfang luncong, March, Issue 1, pp. 100–101. (In Chinese).
Zhang Xiuqin (2007), “Xujia yishi yu huanxiang xianshi: Makesi yu Qizeke yishi xingtai lilun bijiao”, Liaoning daxue xuebao (zhexue shehui kexue ban), No. 7, pp. 14–19. (In Chinese).
Zhang Yibing (2004), “Shehui zhenghou yu fei wanquan baiwujiao–– Qizeke ‘yishi xingtai de chonggao duixiang’ jiedu”, Lilun tantao, No. 5, pp. 23–26. (In Chinese).
Zhang Yibing (2008), Wenben de shendu geng li––di er juan––hou Makesi sichao zhexue wenben jiedu, Zhongguo renmin daxue chubanshe, Beijing. (In Chinese).
Zhang Zhaohui (2018), “Guonei Qizeke dianying lilun yanjiu zongshu”, Beifang wenxue, No. 5, pp. 251–252. (In Chinese).
Zhao Ruifu (2021), “Qizeke de ‘pipan jiaoyu xue’ ji qi dangdai qishi”, Dangdai jiaoyu yu wenhua, No. 3, pp. 11–16. (In Chinese).
Zhou Weigong (2015), “Daode kongju” bian, Jianghuai luntan, No. 5, pp. 104–108. (In Chinese).
Zhou Zhijian, Gao Fujin (2017), “Lun baoli beihou de yinmi tujing—— Qizeke zhengzhi zhexue shijiao”, Makesi zhuyi yu xianshi, No. 1, pp. 132–139. (In Chinese).
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.