РЕЦЕНЗІЯ НА: ƏHMƏDOV S. Ə. AZƏRBAYCAN SILAHLARIIX–XVIIƏSRLƏRDƏ: TƏKAMÜL VƏINKIŞAFI. – BAKI: AFPOLIQRAF, 2017. – 538 s.
##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.main##
##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.sidebar##
Анотація
This review at the monograph of PhD Sabuhi Ahmadov “Azerbaijani weapons in the 9th – 17th centuries: evolution and development” considers the relevance and scientific validity of problem’s formulation as “Azerbaijani weapons”, and notes that the problem of identifying various types of weapons made in Azerbaijan during the Middle Ages is in demand and justified in terms of both geographical attribution and belonging to a certain ethno-cultural space established in a given territory.
In the course of a general assessment of a wide range of diverse sources attracted to the study such as archaeological material, objects of fine art, materials of various domestic and foreign museum funds and personal collections, written sources of epic, poetic, historical heritage, and materials of oral folk art, the value of oriental miniature creativity is especially emphasized as an auxiliary source for the studying of this problem.
It is noted that logical consistency of the structure of the monograph, built on the principle of chronological sequence with the classification of weapons in accordance with the functional purpose such as defensive, offensive, collective is substantial.
The work on the collection and interpretation of multilingual terms related to the military subjects is recognized as a special merit of the monograph.
In general, the article notes the scientific significance of the monograph for studying of the history of military affairs, especially in the aspect of the manufacture and use of various types of weapons in Azerbaijan and neighboring countries in the Middle Ages.
Як цитувати
##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.details##
artifacts, Azerbaijani weapons, cold weapons, firearms, Middle Ages, museum exhibits, tulbend (helmet)
Агаев Ю. Ш., Ахмедов С. А. Ак-Коюнлу-Османская война (1472–1473 гг.). Баку, 2006.
Агаев Ю. Ш., Ахмедов С. А. Военное искусство тюрков в огузском эпосе “Китаби Деде Горгуд”. Баку, 2016.
Бретаницкий Л. С., Веймарн Б. В. Искусство Азербайджана IV–XVIII веков. Москва, 1976.
Гасанзаде Дж. Ю. Зарождение и эволюция Тебризской миниатюрной живописи (XIV–XVI века). Книга первая. Баку, 2016.
Горелик М. В. Оружие Древнего Востока (IV тысячелетие – IV в. до н. э.). Москва, 1993.
Гусейнов Р. Н. Большой Азербайджан в российских, европейских и иных источниках // Ризван Гусейнов. Информационно-аналитический сборник. 2012, 8 июня. URL: https://www.rizvanhuseynov.com/2012/08/3.html (дата звернення: 25.08.2019).
Челеби Эвлия. Книга путешествия. Вып. 3. Земли Закавказья и сопредельных областей Малой Азии и Ирана. Перевод и комментарии / Сост. и отв. ред. А. Д. Желтяков. Примеч. и коммент. А. Желтякова, М. Залумяна и Г. Путуридзе. Москва, 1983.
Эфендиев А. Ч. Батальный жанр в Азербайджанской миниатюрной живописи XIII–XVI веков. Баку, 2009.
Ahmadov S. A. Medieval Azerbaijani weapons in European museums Sabuhi // IRS Heritage, 2017, No. 30.
Alexander D. G. Two Aspects of Islamic Arms and Armor // Metropolitan Museum Journal, 1983, No. 18.
Derbend-nameh. The History of Derbend. Translated from a select Turkish version and published with the texts and with notes by Mirza A. Kazem-Beg. St. Petersburg, 1851.
Əhmədov S. Ə. Azərbaycan silahları IX–XVII əsrlərdə: təkamül və inkişafı. Bakı, 2017.
Əhmədov S. Ə., Cəfərova E. B. Azərbaycanın orta əsr silahları. Bakı, 2005.
Loghat-nama (Dictionnaire Encyclopedique), Fonde par Alo Akbar Dehkhoda (1879–1956), Numero de serie 190, Lettre D Fascicule 5 (b). Teheran, 1973.
Müller H., Künter F. Europaishe helmet. Berlin, 1984.
Zigulski Z. Islamic weapons in Polish collections and their provenance // Elgood Robert (Ed.), Islamic arms and armour. London, 1979.
REFERENCES
Agayev Yu. Sh. and Akhmedov S. A. (2006), Ak-Koyunlu-Osmanskaya voyna (1472–1473 gg.), Elm, Baku. (In Russian).
Agayev Yu. Sh. and Akhmedov S. A. (2016), Voyennoye iskusstvo tyurkov v oguzskom epose “Kitabi Dede Gorgud”, Ol, Baku. (In Russian).
Bretanitskiy L. S. and Veymarn B. V. (1976), Iskusstvo Azerbaydzhana IV–XVIII vekov, Iskusstvo, Moscow. (In Russian).
Gasanzade Dzh. Yu. (2016), Zarozhdeniye i evolyutsiya Tebrizskoy miniatyurnoy zhivopisi (XIV–XVI veka), Book 1, Teknur, Baku. (In Russian).
Gorelik M. V. (1993), Oruzhiye Drevnego Vostoka (IV tysyacheletiye – IV v. do n. e.), Vostochnaya literatura, Moscow. (In Russian).
Guseynov R. N. (2012), “Bol’shoy Azerbaydzhan v rossiyskikh, evropeyskikh i inykh istochnikakh”, in Rizvan Guseynov. Informatsionno-analiticheskiy sbornik, June 8, available at: https://www.rizvanhuseynov.com/2012/08/3.html (accessed 25 August 2019). (In Russian).
Chelebi Evliya (1983), Kniga puteshestviya, Issue 3: Zemli Zakavkaz’ya i sopredel’nykh oblastey Maloy Azii i Irana. Perevod i kommentarii, Compl. by A. D. Zheltyakov, Notes by A. Zheltyakov, M. Zalumyan and G. Puturidze, Nauka, Moscow. (In Russian).
Efendiyev A. Ch. (2009), Batal’nyy zhanr v Azerbaydzhanskoy miniatyurnoy zhivopisi XIII–XVI vekov, Khazar, Baku. (In Russian).
Ahmadov S. A. (2017), “Medieval Azerbaijani weapons in European museums Sabuhi”, in IRS Heritage, No. 30, pp. 24–32.
Alexander D. G. (1983), “Two Aspects of Islamic Arms and Armor”, Metropolitan Museum Journal, No. 18, pp. 97–109.
Derbend-nameh. The History of Derbend. Translated from a select Turkish version and published with the texts and with notes by Mirza A. Kazem-Beg (1851), Printed for the Imperial Academy of Sciences, St. Petersburg.
Əhmədov S. Ə. (2017), Azərbaycan silahları IX–XVII əsrlərdə: təkamül və inkişafı, Afpoliqraf, Bakı. (In Azerbaijani).
Əhmədov S. Ə. and Cəfərova E. B. (2005), Azərbaycanın orta əsr silahları, Elm, Bakı. (In Azerbaijani).
Loghat-nama (Dictionnaire Encyclopedique), Fonde par Alo Akbar Dehkhoda (1879–1956), Numero de serie 190, Lettre D Fascicule 5 (b) (1973), Tehran University Press, Teheran.
Müller H. and Künter F. (1984), Europaishe helmet, Militarverlag, Berlin.
Zigulski Z. (1979), “Islamic weapons in Polish collections and their provenance”, in Elgood Robert (Ed.), Islamic arms and armour, Scolar Press, London, pp. 213–238.
Ця робота ліцензується відповідно до Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.